The Macomb County Michigan Real Estate Blog

head_left_image

Feedback? What feedback?

Is it just me, or is feedback gone the way of the Edsel? Seems today's REALTORS® are too busy showing the vast active inventory available to return feedback. Many times sellers have asked me, "So what did the buyer think"?

I nicely say that I have emailed to agent, faxed a form to the agent requesting feedback and even done something difficult and tried to reach the agent by old fashion telephone. You see, many agents say they are available, but in truth they have voice mail boxes that are full or unchecked. Often the email address we have for the agent is incorrect because they haven't updated their email in the local MLS system. If I can't reach them how many potential buyers/sellers are unable to reach them?

True, times are different than the "good old days", but common courtesy is just that, common courtesy. The sellers were nice enough to accommodate a quick last minute showing, the least today's agent can do is return a message to the listing agent who is requesting feedback.

Your thoughts? Your experience?

www.LookForHomes.com

Comments

I really like the email - I can sit down for a few moments at the end of the day and email everyone with the feed back.  Some systems have the forms emailed automatically -- these are great.  One agent, however, said that the only feedback she wanted to hear was "I have an offer"  (lol)!
Posted by Joan Whitebook, ABR,e-Pro,CEBA Southern New Hampshire (Buyer's Option Realty Services) over 2 years ago
David, You are right. I always respond when a agent e-mails asking for feedback, yet rarely do I call them to give feedback.Simple common courtesy.
Posted by Pat Preston (Shore Realty) over 2 years ago
We've had to be very careful about giving feedback after a buyer sued their agent (no, not for buying too expensive of a home) but for giving the seller too much information and thus losing some bargaining power.
Posted by Matt Thomson Gig Harbor, WA Real Estate & Relocation (Assoc. Broker--Keller Williams Realty) over 2 years ago
I think it is the golden rule.  I find it rude for agents not to provide some sort of feedback, bet they have a seller that would interested in what you and your buyers thought about their home?
Posted by Audrey June-Forshey, GRI, Gaithersburg, MD (RE/MAX Realty Group) over 2 years ago

JOAN:

Thanks for emailing your feedback. I too like to respond to feedback requests when I get them. The bigger problem, like I mentioned, is that many agents in our area are not active emailers. Their email addresses are out of date or mailboxes full. I feel sorry for their clients.

PAT:

Nice to hear from you. Seems like email is simple, straight to the point and efficient.

Posted by David Elya ABR, e-PRO, GRI, SFR - Broker Owner (WEICHERT, REALTORS® - Excel) over 2 years ago
After a showing, I e-mail the agent, thanking them for showing my listing, offering to answer any additional questions they may have, and requesting feedback.  The response rate seems a lot better when done by e-mail, than when leaving a phone message.
Posted by Marilyn Katz - ABR, e-PRO - WestportCTProperties.com (Prudential Connecticut Realty) over 2 years ago
I email all agents that show my listings, but probably less than 1/2 bother to respond.  Calling?  Forget it, they never call back.  Truthfully, most agents don't provide any useful feedback unless they are sharing a problem they had at the property.  How many times can you hear "it doesn't suit my client's needs"?
Posted by Lisa Heindel, New Orleans West Bank Real Estate (Keller Williams Realty Crescent City West Bank Partners) over 2 years ago

I always give feedback when asked, although it is usually difficult to get it when the shoe is on the other foot.  I like email feedback so I can refresh my memory of which property it was;  sometimes, an agent will call weeks later and unless there was something stunningly unique about the property, it's hard to remember. 

I don't like getting requests for feedback, though, from listing agents who want to argue about it.  LOL  Don't shoot the messenger!

And I don't like getting a call while I am STILL WITH THE BUYER!  LOL  Being prompt is great, but calling a half hour after I left the house is just nuts. 

Posted by Susan Haughton Alexandria, VA REALTOR® www.susanmovesyou.com (Long & Foster REALTORS® Old Town Alexandria) over 2 years ago

MATT:

So is honest feedback to the listing agent against the Golden Rule? Or a fine line to be watched in agency law?

Should the buyer agent inform the sellers agent about anything the buyer thought about the property? Should the selling agent even try to gather feedback for their client, the seller?

I think it could work for or against both sides if not careful.

David Elya

Posted by David Elya ABR, e-PRO, GRI, SFR - Broker Owner (WEICHERT, REALTORS® - Excel) over 2 years ago

Common communication courtesy is essential to long term success! I dont understand why some people find it an impossible task and an inconvenience!?!?

To your success!

Susan

Posted by Susan Davis, Van Buren, Fort Smith, AR Real Estate (Higher Impact Marketing) over 2 years ago
David - The online system www.HomeFeedback.com is an amazing system for getting feedback.  This system was designed by top real estate agents selling hundreds of homes each year and I have not seen a feedback product that honestly compares to it.
Posted by Sam Miller (RE/MAX Stars Realty) over 2 years ago
David - I always try to reach them by phone - but if I don't get an answer - I put them on my list.  Then I tell my client if he won't return my call they must not have like the house - Sorry.  Good luck
Posted by Vincent McKamy Realtor Fredericksburg Virginia (RE/MAX Bravo) over 2 years ago
Even with the automated feedback system we have in place, we still don't get a majority of the fedback we request.  I wish I knew why.
Posted by Jim & Maria Hart ~ Charleston, SC Real Estate (AgentOwned Realty) over 2 years ago

LISA:

I hate it when I ask for feedback a day after the showing and the "Good" agent can't remember the property? I probe their memory by saying things like "It's the one with the orange shag carpet" or I try again by saying "It's the house with the badly peeling paint, cracked porch, overgrown lawn" still with no recollection.

 Makes me wonder how that agent remembered their way home?

Posted by David Elya ABR, e-PRO, GRI, SFR - Broker Owner (WEICHERT, REALTORS® - Excel) over 2 years ago
JIM & MARIA:

Is it because many agents/REALTORS are not professional, or is it because they were "raised" that way? It may have started in their youth?
Posted by David Elya ABR, e-PRO, GRI, SFR - Broker Owner (WEICHERT, REALTORS® - Excel) over 2 years ago
i use www.showingfeedback.com and get a very good response rate from agents.  it's a great system and it's free.
Posted by Tina Merritt - Virginia Beach Real Estate (Long and Foster Real Estate) over 2 years ago
Seems to me you handle it well.  I dislike feedback forms when the showing was a couple of weeks ago, or the calls on my cell phone costing me minutes and time I can't spare.  I don't necessarily return all the calls.  I will go out and show 15 properties and have 8 phone calls to return at the end of a long, long day.  Just doesn't work well.  emails, however can be done quickly and efficiently.
Posted by Chris Tesch College Station, Texas Real Estate (RE/MAX Bryan College Station) over 2 years ago

CHRIS:

Thanks for your input. A tip that may work for you that works very well for me is to get a Nextel incoming calls free plan.

I love it when a buyer calls me and I can talk forever if necessary. I post my cell number everywhere. Maybe you hit it on the head, many agents don't want to waste minutes(money) on their cell phone plan?

Posted by David Elya ABR, e-PRO, GRI, SFR - Broker Owner (WEICHERT, REALTORS® - Excel) over 2 years ago

David, I can't agree more.  It's bad when the buyer's agent has a fax, an email, and a voicemail and I still have to call him and talk to him personally to get feedback.  I don't always give immediate feedback but make it point to call them with something within 24 hours.  To me this is just lack of professionalism.

 


Posted by Todd Finch (Leis Realty) over 2 years ago

TODD:

Seems like the deck is stacked against sellers agents in a buyers market. Buyers and their agents are in the drivers seat. DOM is is used against the seller, feedback is non existent.

So much for the code of ethics.

Posted by David Elya ABR, e-PRO, GRI, SFR - Broker Owner (WEICHERT, REALTORS® - Excel) over 2 years ago
David - I provide feedback to every Agent that requests it from me.  Like most Agents, I do not like returning those calls, so the instructions on my outgoing message are simple ... "If you are an Agent calling to get feedback, please visit www.homeshowfeedback.com and submit your question.  I will be sure to respond within 24 hours."  Agents that choose to not obey that and leave a voicemail ... well they very often don't get a call back.  If you ever need to send business to the West 'burbs, let me know ... I will add you as an Associate and keep you in mind for the East side.  Thanks!
Posted by Derek Bauer, Associate Broker - Door To Dreams Team - DoorToDreams.com (Real Estate One) over 2 years ago
David, that is a pet peeve of mine also. Another is when they don't even leave a business card and then don't respond to my feedback requests. My sellers want to know, did they even show their house?
Posted by Mike Mitchell - REALTOR® - St. Clair Shores, MI (Real Living Kee Realty) over 2 years ago

Participate



(optional)
What does the graphic say?